My Model Railroad Question

Sponsored by:

Sponsors have no information about the layouts, sorry
Real Life Quality, unlimited length, 100s of scenes
RailsUSA.Com

Search For Rail Sites

  end sponsors

 
 

 

Home

Search []   

Advanced search
Writer Dennis From Alaska
City, Country
State/Prov AK
Scale Any
KeyWord Polarity

Printer friendly page

Check out my Model Railroad Layout Page on MyRRLayout.com

Polarity, It's Not A City In Western Europe
Response to Question Topic
I am a novice to HO RR. Have a basic layout from Bachmann with DCC. Need detail on how to operate and wire/hookup switches. Is their any schematic or detail handbook to do so? Seem to be missing an interface unit to tie the switches to the control unit. Would appreciate your epert direction. Thanks.

Summary

Having Problems With Your Layout? Trains Not Running? Possibly You Have A Polarity Problem.

I’ve been asked a number of times lately about layouts that just aren’t working correctly. There can be many different reasons why things aren’t working well, but more often than not I find the problems start when there’s a change or addition made. With your basic model railroading electrical wiring there are a few simple rules you need to follow to keep the trains running. And just to make it clear, this discussion deals ONLY with your basic DC (transformer) type system, NOT DCC.

Starting out, I always have people do the obvious. And you would think these should be a “natural”, but many people forget them. Like “Is The Transformer Plugged In”? Sounds silly, but you would be surprised! How about the track? Are all the connectors correctly attached together? Did you clean the track and the train wheels with rubbing alcohol? If you have dirty track or wheels, then the trains won’t run. I clean my track and wheels at least once a week for good performance.

The next thing to remember is never cross the tracks with any metal items. This will create a “short” and cause everything to stop working. If you have only a very simple loop and are having troubles, carefully check to make sure there’s nothing touching the track. Think UNDER the track also. (Is there a piece of Christmas tensile under there?) If you don’t find anything touching the track, next check all of the connections and wire ends. Any breaks, cuts or frayed areas? And finally your transformer might have failed. A Volt/Ohm tester can check this.

Now, if like me you want more action than a simple loop can offer, then you’ve added turnouts (switches). Turnouts are a wonderful fun addition to your layout, but can cause polarity problems. You can think of polarity as the power running in the track. One rail holds a “+” polarity, and the other holds the “-“ (with your standard DC power). With the DCC system, the rules are entirely different, but that’s for another article.

If your trains were running fine before you added a turnout, and now they aren’t then you probably have a “crossed polarity” problem. In the very simplest terms, that means you have set the rails to connect to the wrong sides. I have compiled a few diagrams to help here.

The first diagram shows a very simple siding, either on the inside or the outside of a loop. Look carefully how the inside rail connects to the inside rail, and the outside rail connects to the outside rail. This is a good thing! This should cause no polarity problems.

The second diagram shows a “loop within a loop”. Once again, you’ll notice that the outside rail connects in with the outside rail. And the inside rail connects into the inside rail. All is well here again, with no “crossed polarity”.

Now we come to a couple of “not so good” situations. The next diagram shows a “cross-over” track from one side of the loop to the other. Notice that the inside rail goes to the OUTSIDE rail! This will cause a “crossed polarity” situation, and a complete short. This will cause EVERYTHING on your layout to stop. When you’re setting up any track plan, make sure the outside rail ALWAYS goes to the outside rail, and the same with the inside rail.

And the last diagram shows a “turn-around” or return loop. Once again, notice how when the track comes together the outside rail connects into the INSIDE rail! And again, you have a “crossed polarity” and a complete short.

In the simplest terms, these last two diagrams show us a situation that will completely shut down your railroad. But what if you really want the track to go like that? Well, yes you CAN make the tracks go like that. But that’s another article all together.

For now, just remember to follow the rails from one turnout to the next to make sure the inside rail ends up with the inside rail, and the same with the outside rail. If things still don’t work, try removing the turnout all together and see if it works then. Sometimes these electrical problems can be tricky, but not impossible.

GOOD1 e.jpg

click on image for an expanded view

Good Sideing
GOOD2 e.jpg

click on image for an expanded view

Good Loop In A Loop
BAD1 e.jpg

click on image for an expanded view

Bad Cross Over
BAD2 e.jpg

click on image for an expanded view

Bad Reversing Loop

The information contained here is the sole responsibility of the writer. It is the writer''s responsibility to give credit to manufacturers and give an honest evaluation of products mentioned. The writer assumes only limited responsibility as we will remove any offending article after being notified. We will remove any article that we feel is not in the best interests of a manufacturer or product.  We will remove any article that a manufacturer of that product feels is not in their best interest after being notified by email that they wish to have the article removed and reason. We will verify that the email is from the manufacturer. All articles are displayed on this web as is. We accept no responsibility for the contents of the article with the exception of removing offending articles after being notified by email with traceable source and reason. For further information on liability and terms click here